Partnership - aims and challenges
Within the BIDF regional network More...
CIL Serbia organised a workshop More...
CIL Serbia held its Annual Assembly More...
CIL Serbia organised two trainings More...
Representatives from 17 CSOs signed contracts More...
Educating Students with Disabilities: Some Say It's Not Worth It
Kristina Chew, 21 June 2010 I
n the case of students with disabilities---autism like my son Charlie and with multiple disabilities---what ought to be the main focus? Is it academics or more functional areas like life skills and vocational training? Keep in mind that many of these students will not be attending college and may only be able to work in sheltered workplaces, and/or assisted by job coaches.
Is that the way we should be thinking or are we undermining what these students might potentially learn by not 'rounding out' what they are taught to include lessons in literature, in social studies, science?
An Enormous Challenge
This question is highlighted in a June 19th New York Times article about the struggles of public schools to teach students with multiple, severe disabilities. The plight of 20-year-old Donovan Forde is highlighted: as a result of a traumatic brain injury that happened when he was only 5 months old, Donovan cannot walk or talk. Should he be learning subjects like science and English, the curricula very much adapted to accommodate his cognitive disabilities?
Donovan’s mother, Michelle Forde, likes his special education high school, Public School 79, the Horan School, in East Harlem, where she feels he is welcome and cared for. But she wishes his teachers would spend more time working on his practical challenges, like his self-abusive habit of hitting himself in the face so hard that he has to wear thick white cotton mitts most of the time, even when he sleeps.
Instead of having him work on basic academic goals, like identifying shapes and coins, she wishes he had physical therapy more than 30 minutes, twice a week, because it is generally the only time during the day he is taken out of his wheelchair, except when an aide takes him to the bathroom to change him.
A quick glance at some (thankfully not all of) the comments to the New York Times article suggests---more than unfortunately---that many people have a long way to go as far as understanding why all students have the right to a free and appropriate public education.
Writes one reader in a comment that over 300 people 'recommended' (I didn't):We are spending 5 to 10 times as much on students who will never be the backbone of society, never be able to consistently hold a job. Indeed, many will be shuffled off to expensive group-home settings. Many more will be wards of the State in other, less desirable ways. In our desire to do everything for everyone, state and federal politicians and lobbying interests have carved out special-niche mandates that significantly reduce our ability to serve those who will one day serve our country best.
Providing an education for students like Donovan and for Charlie is not a waste of resources. Far from it, it's a sign of the humanity of our society and---I know I sound idealistic here, but so be it---of what sets our society apart, that it's the law to educate students with disabilities.
My son Charlie can talk a little and he does not have any physical disabilities. As Charlie has gotten older, more and more of his learning has been what is called 'functional'; has been about teaching him 'skills' that involve 'self-care' and 'daily living' (teeth brushing, household chores) and that, it's hoped, might prepare him for some kind of job. He still receives speech therapy and occupational therapy, with the subject matter of both of these determined according to what might best help him in his day-to-day experiences, needs and interactions.
Charlie does not read; he's currently working on various sight words for places, things and the like. Since he was in preschool, teachers and therapists have been trying numerous methods and curricula to teach him the alphabet and reading. It was just a few years ago that Charlie mastered the alphabet (he is 13 years old). I still always feel the tug of hope: Maybe, maybe, and who knows but perhaps Charlie is able to read much more than he appears to, but just hasn't revealed this yet to us. That is, Charlie is not being taught to read with a view towards reading books but to help him navigate the world a little better. And isn't that what reading is for, for many?
Still, I often feel a tug: Shouldn't we be challenging Charlie more? Have we 'given in'? Charlie is only 13 years old; isn't it too early to have 'narrowed' his education down to teaching him the skills for a job?And then I feel exactly like Donovan's mother, who, as quoted in the New York Times, says ' “The only goal I had for him was when he was in the hospital after the accident, when the nurse told me he wasn’t going to live......He’s here, and he’s 20 years old. So he surpassed his goal. He’s alive.”
Yes, Donovan is here and Charlie is here, as are so many students with disabilities and we need to make sure that they have access to the education that they need. I believe the onus is upon us all to keep finding new and different ways to teach students with so many different needs, to do all that we can to help them learn and grow and achieve their full potential.
It's the least that we can do.
Regional Balkan network of DPOs
State of the World's Children
Process of adoption of the Law on Personal Assistance in Slovenia
Every child needs a teacher
Hall of Fame: Gordana Rajkov, CIL Serbia
ENIL’s key definitions on Independent Living
The Projected Image: A History of Disability in Film
HUMAN RIGHTS DAY - 10 December 2012
Education for Personal Assistants
PLACE FOR US
Recognize how your stories influence your experience
Fair of Civil Society Organisations
PLACE FOR US
Europe 2020 Strategy
International Day of Persons with Disabilities, 3 December 2012
Seven Reasons to Attend a Job Fair
A PLACE FOR US
ZRENJANIN – CITY FOR ALL
A PLACE FOR US
Joint Committee publishes report on the implementation of the right of disabled people to independent living
The Cost of Disabilities Could Reach 77.2% of Household Income
Ministry for Labor and Social Policy: The First Fair on social protection in Serbia
Call for Submissions
The World Heritage Convention – 40 Anniversary
LAWSUIT CASES IN THE WORLD
Regional Conference on Independent Living
Enjoying the same rights
The Arts Edition
A PLACE FOR US
World Bank Projects Sluggish Growth for the South East European Economies in 2011 and 2012
International Day of PWDs
My Daughter is Leaving Home: Reflections on Living Independently
A PLACE FOR US
MIDWAT - phase II
II MODULE - QUALITY STANDARDS IN SERVICE PROVIDING
New ENIL EC member from Serbia
Center for Independent Living Serbia OSI at the Serbia-EU Forum
FREEDOM DRIVE 2011
STUDY VISIT TO SLOVENIA
Step by step to the project
International Day of Persons with Disabilities, 3 December 2011
The right for work for PWDs
Development of Nis municipalities
A Place for Us
"The steps on the path of development" project
DISABLED TO KEEP FIGHTING FOR BETTER EU AIR SERVICES
Capacity building of CSOs for social services
Study visit to Budapest
CIL Serbia celebrated 15 years of work
Second seminar in Mataruska banja
Disability Convention Receives 100th Ratification
Workers With Disabilities: An Untapped Resource
A PLACE FOR US
Law for social protection
TRIBUNE “EDUCATION FOR ALL”
PLACE FOR US
Kampaign for Inclusive Education
EU RATIFIED CRPD
Good finish of 2010
THE BEST POSSIBLE NEW YEAR WISH COME TRUE
Advocacy for PA service in Novi Beograd
Comissioner for equality protection
International Day of Persons with Disability
Public transport in Belgrade
REGIONAL ROUND TABLE DEBATE
The Invisibles: disabled people in Britain
Organisations of Civil Society as service providers in social protection area
Mexico in Debt to the Disabled
Fourth workshop on CRPD
SERBIAN CANDIDATE IN UN COMMITTEE
Virtual Career and Education Day expands regionally!
Center for employment of persons with disability
LEGAL HELP TO FAMILIES OF CHILDREN WITH DISABILITY
New initiative in Bor
Promotion of project „Support to independent living of persons with disability in Serbia”
Special Advisor for International Disability Rights